WOMEN’S BODIES: MORE ABOUT CERVICAL BARRIERS
How effective are cervical barriers?
It’s difficult to give a firm answer. Results of studies have been highly variable, ranging from almost none to more than 20 pregnancies per hundred woman-years. As usual, there are less failures with longer use (practice makes perfect), with older women and in women who want no more children. Success is dependent on correct and consistent use.
Types available
Each type of diaphragm and cap available comes in a range of sizes and must be fitted by someone with knowledge and training, usually a doctor or nurse.
The diaphragm fits into the groove behind the pubic bone and is held in place by the muscles in the vaginal wall. It forms an inner ‘roof that covers the cervix. It not only stops the semen from reaching the cervix but keeps cervical mucus from reaching the semen and providing a ‘track’ along which sperm can swim into the cervical canal. Diaphragms provide for differences in anatomy and muscle tone of the vagina with a choice of three different types of spring in the rim.
Cervical caps are thimble-shaped and fit over the cervix, staying in place by suction of the rim around the cervix. Such a cap is only suitable for a woman who has a long cervix that will fit far enough into the cap to maintain suction.
The vault cap (Dumas cap) is placed over the cervix and attaches itself to the surrounding vaginal wall (vaginal vault) by suction. It is suitable for a woman with a short cervix. The Vimule cap is a combination of cervical and vault cap, which hugs the cervix and attaches to the vaginal vault by suction.
In Australia diaphragms are much more popular and easy to get than caps. You would probably have to go to a specialist in contraception, such as an FPA clinic, to be fitted and supplied with a cap.
Fitting cervical barriers
This involves a pelvic examination to assess the size and shape of your cervix, the depth of your vagina and the tone of its muscles. Several sizes may be tried until the right fit is found. You will then be shown how to insert the barrier and how o check that it is properly in place. You should be given a chance to practice insertion, and have your skill checked. Some providers prefer you to use other contraception until you’ve had a chance to practice in the more relaxed atmosphere of home, and to return at a later date wearing the barrier for checking of its position and size. If you have difficulty with insertion, plastic introducer rods are available for some barriers.
The best posture for insertion is either squatting or standing with one foot raised onto a chair or the toilet seat. The actions and direction of insertion are similar to those of putting in a tampon.
A properly fitted diaphragm rests snugly behind the pubic bone. Because the vagina has no touch sensation beyond 2 cm from the entrance, a cervical barrier that
is correctly fitted and placed can’t be felt. If you can feel it, it’s probably too big or out of place. If your partner can feel the rim of a diaphragm, it’s probably too small.
Should spermicides be used?
For many years the use of additional spermicide has been recommended with cervical barriers. Spermicide adds greatly to the cost and complexity of the method, and its necessity has now been questioned. There have not been enough studies to give a firm answer on whether caps or diaphragms work better with or without spermicide.
At present studies on the efficacy of diaphragms and caps with and without spermicide are proceeding in several centres in Australia and the United Kingdom, but results haven’t yet been reported. Until more information is available, I believe that the use of spermicide is a matter of choice.
*127/31/5*